Powered by The Manning Times

Auditor election results upheld after protest

Voting problems at Davis Station found insufficient to change outcome

Posted

The Clarendon County Board of Voter Registration and Elections voted unanimously Monday, Nov. 16, to uphold the results of the county auditor election following a hearing into allegations that voting problems at the Davis Station precinct prevented some residents from casting ballots on Election Day.

The board acknowledged irregularities in the voting process but determined that the evidence presented did not establish that those problems were sufficient to cast doubt on the outcome of the Nov. 3 election, in which Democratic incumbent Patricia Pringle defeated Republican challenger Kimberly Herbert by 147 votes.

According to results certified Nov. 6, Pringle, who has served as county auditor since July 2003, received 6,835 votes, or 50.52%, while Herbert received 6,688 votes, or 49.43%. Six write-in votes were also recorded.

Herbert filed a formal election protest Nov. 10, alleging that Davis Station voters were unable to cast ballots for more than an hour after polls were scheduled to open at 7 a.m. She also alleged that election workers failed to provide alternative voting options and that some residents left without voting.

During the hearing at the elections office in Manning, Herbert presented her own case, questioning witnesses and arguing that the voting problems may have affected the election's outcome. Pringle was represented by attorneys Skyler Hutto and Eleazer Carter.

The central dispute involved a malfunction of electronic poll books, which are used to check voters in before they receive ballots.

Herbert maintained that the first ballot was not cast at Davis Station until 8:13 a.m., more than an hour after voting was scheduled to begin. She argued that the delay, combined with the alleged failure to provide emergency ballots, may have prevented eligible voters from participating.

James Mirick, a poll watcher at Davis Station, testified that approximately 15 or 16 people were waiting when polls opened. He said the electronic check-in equipment was not functioning and that he counted seven people leaving the polling location before casting ballots.

Mirick testified that one of those voters needed to leave for work in Florence. He said he asked an election worker to obtain a provisional ballot for the individual but received no response.

He also testified that he did not observe election workers offering alternative voting options during the interruption.

During questioning, Mirick acknowledged that he did not obtain the names or contact information of those who left and could not establish whether they eventually returned to vote.

Election workers disputed portions of his account.

Monica Blair Franklin, the precinct's poll clerk, testified that the polling location opened at 7 a.m. but experienced problems with its electronic poll books. She said the elections office was contacted and a technician was dispatched to address the malfunction.

According to Franklin, one electronic poll book was replaced and both machines were reprogrammed before normal operations resumed.

Franklin testified that voters were informed they could cast provisional ballots while the equipment was unavailable, but most chose to wait until the problem was resolved.

Alice Durant, a poll manager at Davis Station, supported that account, testifying that alternative ballots were offered and that she observed only one voter leave and later return.

The conflicting testimony left unresolved how many voters departed during the interruption and whether all were informed of available alternatives. It also did not establish whether any of the seven people Mirick reported seeing leave ultimately failed to cast ballots.

Herbert questioned why paper poll books were not used to check voters in while the electronic equipment was unavailable. During questioning by board members, Franklin acknowledged that paper records were available at the precinct.

The hearing also established a distinction between the electronic poll books and the equipment used to mark and scan ballots. Testimony indicated that the primary malfunction involved the electronic check-in system rather than the ballot-marking devices.

Herbert argued that the interruption was particularly significant because of the narrow election margin and voting patterns at Davis Station.

She maintained that Republican candidates generally received a greater share of their support on Election Day and that a disruption during the morning voting period could have disproportionately affected her campaign.

Certified countywide results show Herbert received 3,902 Election Day votes compared with Pringle's 2,113. Pringle, however, led in early voting, receiving 4,523 votes compared with Herbert's 2,736.

Those figures provided context for Herbert's argument but did not establish how voters who may have left Davis Station would have voted.

Attorneys Skyler Hutto and Eleazer Carter, representing Pringle, argued that an election should not be overturned solely because irregularities occurred. They maintained that Herbert had not presented evidence establishing that enough votes were affected to change the result or make it doubtful.

Hutto cited South Carolina Supreme Court decisions establishing the legal standard for reviewing contested elections, including the principle that election results generally should be upheld unless irregularities materially affect the outcome.

Pringle's attorneys also sought dismissal of the protest before presenting their witnesses, arguing that Herbert had not met the required burden of proof. The board declined to dismiss the matter at that point and continued hearing testimony.

Following the hearing, Vice Chairman Brian Magaw moved to confirm and certify the auditor election results.

Magaw said the evidence established that irregularities occurred but did not demonstrate fraud, constitutional violations or problems sufficient to render the election outcome doubtful.

The board approved the motion unanimously.

Although the protest was unsuccessful, board Chairman Edward Gamble III acknowledged that problems occurred during the election and said the board would address them.

Gamble described some of the issues as personnel matters that would be handled by the board. He did not publicly identify specific disciplinary or corrective actions.

"We just have to keep trying to get better. And for those mistakes, we apologize," Gamble said.

Herbert's written protest had asked the board to investigate the circumstances, review election records, obtain sworn testimony and consider legally available remedies, including a new election if the evidence warranted such action.

The board instead determined that the evidence presented did not justify setting aside the certified results, leaving Pringle's election victory intact.

While the hearing resolved the election protest, questions remain about the number of voters affected by the Davis Station interruption and what corrective measures the board may take to prevent similar problems in future elections.