Opinion: Local news doesn’t pick winners, we tell the whole story
Over the past few weeks, The Manning Times has received a wave of criticism, from headlines being called clickbait to accusations of biased journalism. I want to address those concerns directly, not to defend myself, but to explain our approach and invite a more thoughtful conversation about the role of local news.
First, let me say that we are always listening. We take your comments seriously, and we reflect constantly on how to improve our reporting and our reach. But news isn’t biased just because a reader doesn’t like what it says. A headline’s job is to capture attention and reflect the story. Yes, it should draw you in. But it should never mislead you. When we write about complex local issues, our goal is to present the full picture. Unless it’s Election Day, we don’t declare winners. We report what happened and trust you, the reader, to form your own opinion.
It’s also important to remember that I am not just “the media.” I’m your neighbor.
This fall, my children will be enrolled in Clarendon County School District schools. I buy groceries where you do. I pump gas at the same corner stores. I vote at the same precinct. But when I log onto social media, I’m no longer Melissa. I become “mainstream media,” a target for whatever frustration is boiling that day. I’ve been called biased, careless, even dangerous. I correct my mistakes, because integrity demands it, but I also stand by my reporting.
Let me be blunt: almost every story I write, whether it’s about politics, school board meetings, or town government, makes someone mad on both sides of the issue. I do have personal political views, as we all do, and yet I’m often criticized just as harshly by my own party as I am by the opposition. In fact, I’ve spent so much time working to stay neutral that sometimes it feels like I’ve lost my own voice. But I’ve kept doing it, because it matters. Because facts matter. Because the truth still matters.
Our newsroom isn’t perfect. But it’s thoughtful. It’s made up of people who care deeply about this community. And that’s why we’ve updated our Letters to the Editor policy. Not to filter what you say, but to ensure it’s constructive, respectful, and rooted in shared responsibility. We’ve also implemented a Right to Reply, so that any person or business mentioned in a letter has the opportunity to respond and explain their side of the story.
We need a higher level of critical thinking in our society, and right here in Clarendon County. That starts with a little more neighborliness. A little more grace. A little more willingness to assume the best in people instead of the worst.
I talk to elected officials regularly. Many of them are tired. They are tired of being misrepresented, criticized, and attacked. But they signed up for public service, and accountability comes with the job. Still, it doesn’t have to come with cruelty.
We’re all responsible for the tone of the conversation in our community—from local leaders to grandmas scrolling Facebook on their porches. Let’s raise the standard together.
Melissa Foust-McCoy
Managing Editor